| Platinum | Poco Loco Pineapples |
| Gold | Mrs. Sprinkles Ice Cream |
| Silver | I Scream Ice Cream |
| Bronze | Eve's Tidy Touch |
| Top Pick | Cerealsly Sweet |
| Top Pick | Chaparritas Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | LA Estrella Michoacana |
| Top Pick | Neko Neko Taiyaki and Softserve |
| Top Pick | Pink Pony Soft Serve |
| Top Pick | The Brain Freezer |