| Platinum | Golden Crown Panaderia |
| Gold | Twin Peaks Albuquerque |
| Silver | JC's New York Pizza Department |
| Bronze | Village Pizza |
| Top Pick | Amadeo's Pizza & Subs |
| Top Pick | Dion's |
| Top Pick | Hops N Dough Taproom |
| Top Pick | Old Town Pizza Parlor |
| Top Pick | Pizza Castle |
| Top Pick | Restoration Pizza by Bosque |